This inn was until very recently part of The Arms, located next door, but was bought out and just reopened as its own entity. It's basically an old house being used as an inn, more of an AirBnB-type property than a hotel proper...but that's what I prefer. Our room was comfortable, clean, and very cozy. The new owners, who live in a small house in the back yard, were very nice and readily available. They made check-in and checkout very simple and easy, and had a lot of local information for us. The property is on the main drag in tiny Pine Hill. There are a couple of restaurants within walking distance. No noise issues at all.
The building itself is a bit bedraggled. It's an old house, with things that sag here and there, and a quirky layout. The decor leaves much to be desired - very dated and worn. But it does have its charm. Everything was clean, everything worked, everything was comfortable, so I didn't mind that the stairs lean and the carpet is worn. If you have the right expectations, you'll be perfectly happy here.